Mundy, Bruce C., Richard C. Wass, E. E. DeMartini, Jr., Brian D. Greene, Brian Zgliczynski, Robert E. Schroeder & Craig Musberger. 2010. Inshore Fishes of Howland Island, Baker Island, Jarvis Island, Palmyra Atoll, and Kingman Reef. Atoll Research Bulletin(585): 1-131.

prev | next
59
Line, Phoenix, and northern Cook Islands populations that had been regarded as a color
variant of the widespread Indo-Pacific D. trimaculatus. Bernardi et al. (2002, 2003)
examined genetic relationships of four species in the Dascyllus trimaculatus clade,
including D. auripinnis, and found that D. auripinnis specimens were nested within one
of three clades of D. trimaculatus that might be interpreted as a cryptic species of the
latter. This indicates that D. auripinnis and D. trimaculatus are not monophyletic species.
Bernardi et al. (2002) suggested three hypotheses that might explain this result: that D.
auripinnis is not a valid species, but is only a phenotypic variant of D. trimaculatus;
that the two species are valid but have hybridized with consequent genetic introgression,
or; that D. auripinnis is the result of a recent speciation event with incomplete lineage
sorting with respect to D. trimaculatus. They mentioned that the sympatry of nominal
D. auripinnis with D. trimaculatus at Penrhyn and Suwarrow, northern Cook Islands,
might be taken as evidence for their status as distinct species, presumably based on the
biological species concept, with the implication that their second or third hypotheses
would be favored. Bernardi et al. (2003) commented that if hybridization of the two
morphospecies is occurring at Penrhyn and Suwarrow Islands, their relative abundance
suggests that the D. auripinnis haplotypes would likely introgress those of D.
trimaculatus.
In the Dascyllus trimaculatus clade, the lack of concordance between color
phenotypes diagnostic for nominal species and genetic population structure is very
similar to the lack of concordance found by McMillan et al. (1999) for the nominal
Chaetodon pelewensis and C. punctatofasciatus. The confusing results of these
genetic analyses are an indication of the variety of stages in evolutionary histories in
which lineages of Indo-Pacific shore fishes exist. Rocha et al. (2007) suggested that
in such cases, color and morphological differences diagnostic for morphospecies can
evolve without congruent changes to the portion of the genetic sequences used in
phylogeographic studies to identify genetic species. They suggested that divergence due
to adaptation to local conditions and disruptive natural selection in combination with
assortative mating might be two possible explanations for this discrepancy. In particular,
they suggested that analysis of gene sequences related to color might be necessary to
investigate the relation of morphospecies to genetic species in coral reef fishes.
Rocha et al. (2007) also mentioned that some of the incongruent matches of
genetic lineages with morphological differentiation may be due to hybridization. This is
pertinent to hybridization processes in reticulate patterns of evolution like those proposed
for reef-building corals (Veron, 1995), in which lineages diverge and then rejoin.
Reticulate evolution has received less attention for fish species than for corals, but it is
consistent with the parapatric mode of speciation suggested as the dominant mode for
reef fishes by Rocha and Bowen (2008). Rocha et al. (2007) commented that mtDNA may
flow easily between species in hybrid contact zones, and that phylogeographic patterns
found in mtDNA analyses may not correspond to the evolutionary history of populations
that hybridize, but merely to the history of the mitochondria. Their conclusion was
that mtDNA should not be solely relied upon when hybridization is suspected, and that
nuclear DNA should also be analyzed. By inference, this would be particularly important
for species in which reticulate evolution is a possibility. Reliance on mtDNA alone would
only track maternal contributions to lineage histories, while a combination of mtDNA and

Names found on this page: Atule mate (Cuvier in Cuvier & Valenciennes, 1833);  Caracanthus maculatus (Gray, 1831);  Epinephelus fasciatus (Forsskål, 1775); 
Treatments on page: 59 prev | next Link Occurrences
Name Appearances



Name Author(s) Follow this taxonomy


to
to      Convert:fathoms | feet
Host | Mangroves | Mesophotic Reef | Savanna | Desert | Semi-desert | Rain Forest | Grassland | Woodland | Flood Plain | Wetlands | Agricultural Fields | Marshes | Urban Areas | Pastures | Sand | Lagoon | In coral heads | Estuary/Bay | River | Lake | Reef Flats | Pelagic | Fringing Reef | Wall | Caves | Rubble | Hard substrate | Under Ledge | Wreck | Sea Grass / Algae | Rocks/Boulders | Mud/Silt | Tide Pool clear
Language

Identifier links to individual from location:

Zoology | Botany | All
Taxon Usage:
Taxon Usage:
Synonym Protonym:
Verbatim Spelling:
Follow this synonymy:

Explorer’s LogTM Ver 5.0 All content copyright Technical Innovations, Inc. 1998-2026
User: Rusi | Current Time is 5:36 AM