Mundy, Bruce C., Richard C. Wass, E. E. DeMartini, Jr., Brian D. Greene, Brian Zgliczynski, Robert E. Schroeder & Craig Musberger. 2010. Inshore Fishes of Howland Island, Baker Island, Jarvis Island, Palmyra Atoll, and Kingman Reef. Atoll Research Bulletin(585): 1-131.

prev | next
58
species with a range from the eastern Indian Ocean to the Phoenix Islands and Samoa,
and described C. truncatus as a new Indian Ocean species.
One of the earliest and most enduring recognitions of subspecies in Pacific shore
fishes, for Acanthurus triostegus, used Line and Phoenix Islands specimens to support its
argument. Based on differences in the color pattern below the pectoral-fin base, Schultz
and Woods (1948; as discussed in Schultz and Woods in Schultz et al., 1953) recognized
the subspecies A. t. sandvicensis from the Hawaiian Islands, A. t. marquesensis from
the Marquesas, and A. t. triostegus from elsewhere in the Indo-Pacific. Specimens from
the Phoenix Islands had pectoral-fin base markings that included variations seen in all
three subspecies, as well as intermediate states. The Phoenix Islands specimens were
used to argue that incomplete but clearly evident morphological differentiation indicated
evolution to a point at which subspecies, but not distinct species, could be recognized.
Although A. sandvicensis has sometimes been recognized as a full species, the conclusion
of Schultz and Woods (1948) was accepted by the subsequent, more detailed research of
Randall (1956, 2001b). However, Lessios and Robertson (2006) presented evidence that
the genetic divergence of A. t. sandvicensis from eastern Pacific and Line Islands A. t.
triostegus populations is at a level found between species in other genera.
At a different point along the species-definition spectrum, Gill and Kemp (2002)
gave Epinephelus fasciatus as an example of a taxon currently considered to be a single
species that might be split into several species. They noted that in the last review of the
genus, Randall and Heemstra (1991) recognized six diagnosable geographic forms. The
latter authors stated that “It is clear that the population of E. fasciatus on the Pacific Plate
has diverged from elsewhere, but in our opinion not at the species level” and they also
considered the Marquesan population similarly differentiated. Randall and Heemstra
(1991) concluded that “In our opinion more material and more exhaustive study are
needed before attempting to recognize any of these populations nomenclaturially [sic].”
In an example that resulted in a conclusion counter to the prevailing trend to
recognize geographically restricted species among populations of a formerly recognized
widespread species, McMillan et al. (1999) argued that the butterflyfish species pair
Chaetodon punctatofasciatus and C. pelewensis are populations divergent in phenotype
in which color differences are maintained by selection pressures despite a lack of genetic
isolation. They concluded that continued recognition of the color variants as distinct
species was impossible “under most current species definitions”, a recommendation
accepted by Smith et al. (2003), who synonymized the species. This example
demonstrates how the “recognition concept” for species definition discussed by Cracraft
(2002) has failed to resolve the old problem of creating a definition for the concept
“species”. In the example of C. punctatofasciatus/pelewensis, opposing conclusions about
the status of the two species are largely due to the criteria, genetic vs. phenotypic, used to
identify the smallest clusters of populations in which individual specimens can be reliably
diagnosed as distinct from individuals from other clusters. This problem, therefore,
continues to affect biogeographic analysis by use of techniques of species inventories and
analyses of the ranges of endemic species.
A last example also illustrates the occasional discrepancy between changing
morphological species concepts and the results of genetic analysis of population
relationships. Dascyllus auripinnis was described by Randall and Randall (2001b) for

Names found on this page: Epinephelus Bloch, 1793;  Atule mate (Cuvier in Cuvier & Valenciennes, 1833);  Epinephelus fasciatus (Forsskål, 1775); 
Treatments on page: 58 prev | next Link Occurrences
Name Appearances



Name Author(s) Follow this taxonomy


to
to      Convert:fathoms | feet
Host | Mangroves | Mesophotic Reef | Savanna | Desert | Semi-desert | Rain Forest | Grassland | Woodland | Flood Plain | Wetlands | Agricultural Fields | Marshes | Urban Areas | Pastures | Sand | Lagoon | In coral heads | Estuary/Bay | River | Lake | Reef Flats | Pelagic | Fringing Reef | Wall | Caves | Rubble | Hard substrate | Under Ledge | Wreck | Sea Grass / Algae | Rocks/Boulders | Mud/Silt | Tide Pool clear
Language

Identifier links to individual from location:

Zoology | Botany | All
Taxon Usage:
Taxon Usage:
Synonym Protonym:
Verbatim Spelling:
Follow this synonymy:

Explorer’s LogTM Ver 5.0 All content copyright Technical Innovations, Inc. 1998-2026
User: Rusi | Current Time is 5:26 AM