Mundy, Bruce C., Richard C. Wass, E. E. DeMartini, Jr., Brian D. Greene, Brian Zgliczynski, Robert E. Schroeder & Craig Musberger. 2010. Inshore Fishes of Howland Island, Baker Island, Jarvis Island, Palmyra Atoll, and Kingman Reef. Atoll Research Bulletin(585): 1-131.

prev | next
56
understanding of morphological differences among populations, but it is also partly due
to changes in the definition of “species” (Isaac et al., 2004). The literature on species
concepts is too voluminous and contentious to be reviewed here, but it has resulted
in several competing theories about what the systematic level “species” is and how it
should be defined (e. g., Wheeler and Meier, 2000; K. de Quiroz, 2005). Nevertheless,
the practices of most recent ichthyologists working on Indo-Pacific shore fishes appear
to conform with Cracraft’s (2002) suggestion that, regardless of which species definition
they favor, taxonomists are converging on the practical solution of recognizing species
as the smallest clusters of populations in which individual specimens can be reliably
diagnosed as distinct from individuals from other clusters. Emphasis on the smallest
clusters leads to a recognition of greater numbers of species, often with limited
geographic ranges (Isaac et al., 2004). This concept corresponds approximately with the
secondary level of diagnosable species in K. de Queiroz’s (2005) unified lineage species
concept. This is the level at which nonexclusive species diagnoses are avoided (McCabe,
2008), a condition regarded by us as useful even though it was explicitly rejected as
a consequence of K. de Queiroz’s (2005) unified species concept. For Indo-Pacific
shore fishes the trend toward recognizing species as the smallest clusters of populations
that can be exclusively diagnosed as distinct has perhaps been given its most extreme
advocacy by Gill (1999) and Gill and Kemp (2002). They argued that all subspecies or
other diagnosable geographic variants of shore-fish taxa should be recognized and named
as full species. But, as has long been recognized, the variability in relative character-
state frequencies in populations of Indo-Pacific species, as a likely consequence of the
different temporal positions of populations in their evolutionary trajectories, makes this
extreme position operationally less useful than Gill (1999) and Gill and Kemp (2002)
advocate.
The present state of Pacific shore-fish taxonomy includes recognition of a gradient
of diversification among populations, subspecies, and species that reflects an acceptance
of evolution as a continuing process at varying stages of differentiation within clades.
Populations that have diverged in character states to the point at which they can be
consistently and unequivocally diagnosed are recognized as distinct species. Populations
that have diverged to points at which only the majority of individuals can be diagnosed,
or populations that are diagnosed by statistical analyses such as by mean or modal values
of counts, are usually recognized as subspecies, varieties, or unnamed morphs. Some
are simply described as having geographic differences that may be clinal or that have
phenotypic differences maintained by selection pressures despite gene flow among the
populations. We argue that the resolution of all taxa to absolutely distinct species or even
completely diagnosable subspecies is incongruent with an acceptance of evolution as
an active and ongoing process, regardless of which species concepts are used. Although
most Indo-Pacific shore-fish taxa may be at periods of stasis in cladogenesis (Gould,
2002), there is good evidence that some taxa are at various stages in cladal differentiation
that may, or may not, result in their speciation. The range of differentiation in species
integrity from incipient to complete is predicted if, as Rocha and Bowen (2008) have
argued, parapatry is the prevalent mode of speciation for reef fishes.
The full range of operational and theoretical interpretations of species definitions
can be found in fishes from the U.S. Line and Phoenix Islands. These include several
examples of how the increased availability of larger sample sizes from various

Names found on this page: Atule mate (Cuvier in Cuvier & Valenciennes, 1833); 
Treatments on page: 58 prev | next Link Occurrences
Name Appearances



Name Author(s) Follow this taxonomy


to
to      Convert:fathoms | feet
Host | Mangroves | Mesophotic Reef | Savanna | Desert | Semi-desert | Rain Forest | Grassland | Woodland | Flood Plain | Wetlands | Agricultural Fields | Marshes | Urban Areas | Pastures | Sand | Lagoon | In coral heads | Estuary/Bay | River | Lake | Reef Flats | Pelagic | Fringing Reef | Wall | Caves | Rubble | Hard substrate | Under Ledge | Wreck | Sea Grass / Algae | Rocks/Boulders | Mud/Silt | Tide Pool clear
Language

Identifier links to individual from location:

Zoology | Botany | All
Taxon Usage:
Taxon Usage:
Synonym Protonym:
Verbatim Spelling:
Follow this synonymy:

Explorer’s LogTM Ver 5.0 All content copyright Technical Innovations, Inc. 1998-2026
User: Rusi | Current Time is 5:07 AM