Mundy, Bruce C., Richard C. Wass, E. E. DeMartini, Jr., Brian D. Greene, Brian Zgliczynski, Robert E. Schroeder & Craig Musberger. 2010. Inshore Fishes of Howland Island, Baker Island, Jarvis Island, Palmyra Atoll, and Kingman Reef. Atoll Research Bulletin(585): 1-131.

prev | next
53
Sampling Biases in Our Surveys
The absence in our surveys of some species, from the Line and Phoenix Islands,
recorded by others may be due in part to the focus of our efforts on moderately shallow
reef habitats. We likely missed almost all sand-dwelling species such as Cymolutes
praetextatus, Iniistius species, Parapercis species, many microdesmids, most burrowing
gobiids, callionymids, bothids, and samarids. We also did not record deeper-dwelling
reef species such as Pseudanthias aurulentus, Bodianus sepiacaudus, or Pseudocheilinus
ocellatus.
Many of the littoral species collected in numbers by early expeditions to these
islands were absent or rare in our observations because we did not survey shallow
shoreline habitats well. Examples of such littoral species include Gymnothorax pictus,
Epinephelus socialis, Chrysiptera glauca, Abudefduf septemfasciatus, and Abudefduf
sordidus. The numerous specimens of Gymnothorax pictus in older collections may be
due to its shallow, often intertidal, habitat. Intertidal observations were not made in our
surveys.
Williams et al. (2006) found at Wallis Island that the Carangidae, Caesionidae,
Lethrinidae, Chaetodontidae, Scaridae, Scombridae, and Tetraodontidae were recorded
only in visual scuba surveys and not with rotenone or spear sampling. These families
were among those that we found to be well sampled by our visual surveys.
Most of the species known from the Line and Phoenix Islands that we did not
record at the five U.S. islands were small, nocturnal, or otherwise cryptic species. A
few cryptic species recorded in our surveys were only represented by larvae collected
in plankton tows around Palmyra Atoll in 1990 and 1992. These included species in
the Bythitidae, Gobiesocidae, Gobiidae, Microdesmidae, and Schindleriidae. Williams
et al. (2006) found that about 43% of the fish species that they recorded from Wallis
Island were only sampled by rotenone collections. Those species were primarily in the
Muraenidae, Ophichthidae, Bythitidae, Antennariidae, Holocentridae, Scorpaenidae,
Apogonidae, Creediidae, Blenniidae, Gobiesocidae, and Gobiidae. In the western North
Atlantic, where the fish fauna is less similar to the Line and Phoenix Islands than that
of Wallis Island, rotenone collections revealed that otherwise unsampled cryptic species
comprised 45.5% of the fish fauna of Navassa Island (Collette et al. (2003) and about
56% at Buck Island National Monument, St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands (Smith-Vaniz
et al., 2006). The results of Collette et al. (2003), Williams et al. (2006), and Smith-
Vaniz (2006) suggest that the 22% of the Line and Phoenix Islands fauna not sampled
by our visual surveys may greatly underestimate the number of cryptic species still to be
discovered at these islands.
Samples of small, nocturnal, or otherwise cryptic fish species from the Line and
Phoenix Islands would increase our understanding of the fish assemblages there and the
biogeography of the region’s ichthyofauna. Rotenone sampling has been advocated as the
most suitable method of collecting these species (Collette et al., 2003; Smith-Vaniz, 2006;
Williams et al., 2006; Robertson and Smith-Vaniz, 2008) despite popular antipathy to its
use from misconceptions about its effects and the persistence of its impacts (Robertson
and Smith-Vaniz, 2008). Conservation management of the five U.S. islands as U.S. Fish
and Wildlife Service wildlife refuges prohibits the use of rotenone or other ichthyocides

Names found on this page: Antennariidae;  Apogonidae Günther 1859;  Bythitidae;  Carangidae;  Holocentridae Richardson, 1846;  Microdesmidae;  Muraenidae;  Scorpaenidae;  Apogon Lacépède, 1801;  Epinephelus Bloch, 1793;  Gymnothorax Bloch, 1795;  Pseudanthias Bleeker in Bleeker, 1871;  Aetobatus ocellatus (Kuhl in van Hasselt 1823);  Atule mate (Cuvier in Cuvier & Valenciennes, 1833);  Epinephelus fasciatus (Forsskål, 1775);  Epinephelus socialis (Günther 1873);  Gymnothorax pictus (Ahl, 1789); 
Treatments on page: 53 prev | next Link Occurrences
Name Appearances



Name Author(s) Follow this taxonomy


to
to      Convert:fathoms | feet
Host | Mangroves | Mesophotic Reef | Savanna | Desert | Semi-desert | Rain Forest | Grassland | Woodland | Flood Plain | Wetlands | Agricultural Fields | Marshes | Urban Areas | Pastures | Sand | Lagoon | In coral heads | Estuary/Bay | River | Lake | Reef Flats | Pelagic | Fringing Reef | Wall | Caves | Rubble | Hard substrate | Under Ledge | Wreck | Sea Grass / Algae | Rocks/Boulders | Mud/Silt | Tide Pool clear
Language

Identifier links to individual from location:

Zoology | Botany | All
Taxon Usage:
Taxon Usage:
Synonym Protonym:
Verbatim Spelling:
Follow this synonymy:

Explorer’s LogTM Ver 5.0 All content copyright Technical Innovations, Inc. 1998-2026
User: Rusi | Current Time is 4:39 AM